Amanda the Adventurer by MANGLEDmaw Games (published by DreadXP) released in 2023 and quickly became a standout in the analog horror genre. You play as Riley, who inherits her aunt's house and discovers a box of VHS tapes in the attic featuring a children's cartoon — except the cartoon character, Amanda, begins responding directly to you and the story grows increasingly sinister. The game collected strong reviews for its unsettling atmosphere and multiple endings.
The horror here isn't jump scares — it's the slow creep of wrongness as Amanda and her sheep companion Wooly say and do things that a children's cartoon absolutely should not. Puzzles are woven into the tape-watching mechanic: you interact by typing answers to Amanda's questions and clicking objects on screen. Solving every puzzle correctly unlocks a deeper, darker layer of the story.